Artificial intelligence (AI) is transforming everything, from digital assistants in cybersecurity to personalized experiences in retail. But in health care, AI holds even greater promise: the ability to streamline systems, reduce administrative burdens, and improve access to quality care at scale. In the world of pharmacy benefits, a forward-thinking AI strategy can ease complexity, reduce delays, and elevate both provider and patient experiences.
Pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) and employee benefits leaders are beginning to embrace AI for its transformative potential. From streamlining prior authorizations (PA) and claims to anticipating patient needs through predictive and prescriptive analytics, generative AI enables more efficient, proactive benefits management. But even as automation advances, human judgment and empathy must remain central to patient care.
The integration of AI into pharmacy benefits management is raising critical questions. How should PBMs use AI responsibly? Is it truly improving patient care, or simply speeding up operations at the cost of the human element that defines quality health care? Will high-touch support be sacrificed in favor of automation? And what benefits should managers and advisors be asking of their PBM partners to ensure that technology enhances, rather than replaces, the human element?
PBMs and benefits executives increasingly need automation to streamline administration. From reducing paperwork to optimizing workflows, AI offers powerful ways to free up human experts for higher-value work. But even as automation advances, one key consideration must remain front and center: the irreplaceable role of human connection in health care.
Where human connection can make the difference
AI can simplify workflows, but it should never replace the human insight and compassion critical to patient care. While AI can assist with data gathering or initial screening, it cannot replace human judgment, clinical context, or compassion.
A recent survey found that 61% of physicians are concerned about AI’s impact on PA denials, citing risks to patient safety and rising costs. Similarly, 68% of pharmacists reported concerns about the accuracy of AI-generated information. These aren’t just theoretical concerns; they represent real risks to patient safety when decisions lack human oversight.
In this context, clinical review of every PA remains essential. It can mean the difference between a delayed, compromised patient experience and one that supports recovery and positive outcomes. When the human element is stripped away, it can lead to confusion, missed context and unnecessary health care costs.
The role of AI in supporting — not replacing — human care
AI can still play a meaningful, supportive role. For example, it can help flag drug interactions, alert care coordinators about patients who might require extra attention proactively and in a timely manner, suggest alternative therapies, or pre-fill documentation that would otherwise burden health care teams. Used this way, AI doesn't replace clinicians; it empowers them to spend more time with patients and make better informed decisions.
But pharmacy benefits are often deeply personal and complex. Whether facing a new diagnosis, a specialty medication, or a confusing benefits policy, patients often have questions that require personalized, empathetic guidance. In these moments, patients don’t need a chatbot or a generic FAQ page. They need a human who can listen, explain and guide them.
A patient-forward approach to a high-touch dilemma
The best pharmacy benefits strategies strike a deliberate balance between high-tech tools and high-touch service. Benefits managers must ask themselves: Would I want my team navigating pre-recorded prompts to get help with a new medication or talking to a qualified professional who understands their needs?
The answer is clear.
Human connection is not a luxury in health care; it’s a necessity. And it should be a standard that employers and benefits advisors expect, not hope for, when choosing a PBM partner.
The true differentiator isn’t just who’s using AI, but how they’re using it. A truly patient-forward PBM will harness technology to improve speed, accuracy and access, while doubling down on empathy, clinical quality and service.
The way you balance AI-driven tools with human connection directly impacts employee satisfaction, productivity, health and wellbeing, and can make or break your pharmacy benefits strategy. Employers and advisors should not only expect this level of care and understanding from their PBM, but they should demand it.
© Arc, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to TMSalesOperations@arc-network.com. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.