Health care is politically charged and financially stressful for most Americans. Nearly 9 in 10 say it influences their vote; almost two-thirds worry that their household's health care expenses could force serious financial sacrifices; and more than 4 in 10 say affordability already has caused them to delay care, skip medication or put off a health decision in the past year.
"Americans are not united around a single health care fear," according to the inaugural SachsHEALTH Influence Index. "Their anxieties are scattered. This fragmentation makes it harder for health care professionals, elected leaders and others to communicate in a way that hits home broadly. It also makes it harder to implement changes that feel meaningful to the masses."
The index offers six strategic insights into public trust in the health care system.
Trust is fragile, and distrust changes behavior. Just half of Americans trust the health care system to act in patients' best interests. More than 4 in 10 have acted against a clinician's advice in the past year because of that distrust. This behavior is active noncompliance, not passive skepticism.
Clinicians should speak up. Americans want the medical professionals with whom they interact directly (doctors, nurses, pharmacists and caregivers) to have greater influence over the health care system. Clinicians have the widest gap between perceived influence and desired influence of any group measured.
Patients want real doctors, not robots. The trust Americans feel for their clinicians could easily be broken if it seems that doctors are replacing real relationships -- and real clinical decision-making -- with AI.
Local beats federal. Americans trust local and state health departments more than the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the Food and Drug Administration and the Department of Health and Human Services. The pattern is identical among liberals and conservatives, and skepticism toward federal public health institutions is structural, not partisan.
Affordability matters. More than half of Americans name affordability as a top health care concern, but after that, the field scatters without consensus. Cost anxiety is pervasive and nonpartisan.
Blame doesn't require authorship. A group may be blamed for an issue it never drove. Elected officials rank in the middle of the pack in shaping the cost narrative but catch the second-largest share of blame when costs rise, behind only insurers.
Paradoxically, Americans trust their clinicians but often act against their advice because they suspect it may be influenced by distant industry forces outside the clinician's control.
"That's the invisible hand of health care and telling patients to trust harder will not close the gap," the report said. "The prescribed medication may be the one the pharmacy benefit manager's formulary allowed. The follow-up advice may hinge on what the insurer will cover.
"Instead, by prioritizing transparency, we can make the invisible hand visible so health recommendations can stand on their own, rather than on blind faith in the system that produced them."
© Arc, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to TMSalesOperations@arc-network.com. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.