Are millennials financially savvy, or are they too fiscally naïve to watch out for their own best interests? The answer might depend on which source you consult.

While Credit Karma is saying millennials are more financially savvy than their current reputations indicate, Bankrate is saying that they either are not savvy enough to be in the stock market or don’t have enough disposable income to invest.

Credit Karma provides free credit scores (although not the FICO scores used by most banks) and credit monitoring to consumers, albeit with the assistance of targeted advertising that recommends financial products to users based on the information they provide. Those ads and recommendations are how Credit Karma pays its bills.

The site also provides a way to dispute credit score errors — something that could save millennials lots of money on interest payments when applying for loans their scores qualify them for.

Bankrate, for its part, offers all sorts of financial advice, as well as analysis of bank interest rates, mortgages, credit cards, insurance and other products and services. Its most recent Bankrate Money Pulse survey finds that millennials are slower to invest in stocks than other age groups; while 54 percent of Americans don’t invest, only a third of millennials do. And only 18 percent of those between 18 and 25 are investing.

But is this because they’re financially ignorant of the potential stocks offer, or because they don’t have the money? Millennial survey respondents cited the latter as the reason, with 46 percent giving that as their reason. However, the second most-cited reason was not knowing enough about stocks.

There’s a possibility that a third reason has a lot to do with their abstention from investing, of course — a distrust of the stock market, especially after seeing what it did to parents and grandparents during the Great Recession. In fact, a study last year from Northwestern Mutual found that they were “old souls” when it came to money, “quite conservative and risk-averse.”

Some of the Credit Karma data bear this out. Among the 38 percent of millennials who said they have not taken out credit cards, Credit Karma found that 48 percent cited an aversion to debt as their top reason.

Instant Insights /

Millennials&rsquo; financial wisdom is supported, challenged

More From HR Executive

Related Stories

Recommended For You

Millennials’ financial wisdom is supported, challenged