Hope for greater fee transparency

The settlement in a fiduciary-duty suit against MassMutual Life Insurance Co. appears to open the door to further legal action by plan sponsors in a similar arrangement with other providers.

By Greg Carpenter | November 10, 2014 at 08:17 AM

MassMutual's actions in the lawsuit Golden Star Inc. v. MassMutual Life Insurance Co. were never in dispute. The financial giant oversaw variable annuity investments in the plaintiff's plan and received both direct compensation from plan participants and indirect compensation – in the form of revenue sharing – from other mutual fund companies. These revenue sharing payments were not disclosed to the plan sponsor.

The key issue was whether MassMutual was a "functional fiduciary" as defined by ERISA. If they are not a fiduciary, as MassMutual contended, there is no breach of standards. If deemed a fiduciary, receiving the undisclosed compensation creates a prohibited transaction under ERISA, and potentially large liability.

Recommended For You

Under ERISA, plan service providers who exercise discretionary authority over plan assets may be deemed a "functional fiduciary." As a functional fiduciary, the provider is held to a higher standard of conduct to act exclusively in the interests of plan participants, and it is subject to significant liability if those standards are not met.

A federal judge ruled for the plaintiff and declared MassMutual to be a functional fiduciary under ERISA. Her reasoning was that MassMutual had the ability to set its own compensation without consulting with the plan sponsor, effectively giving MassMutual discretionary authority over plan's assets. Even though MassMutual did not admit liability in the settlement, the implications are large for other plan providers who may be in similar circumstances.

In the settlement, MassMutual will pay out over $9 million in cash compensation, give a 60-day window for any planned fund changes, and, most importantly, clearly disclose fees and expense ratios in plan funds as well as any revenue sharing payments it receives.

The ruling and settlement appear to open the door to further legal action by plan sponsors in a similar arrangement with other providers.  While not all providers with revenue sharing may be deemed fiduciaries, the risk of potential liability may cause many to evaluate their fee disclosure procedures and make pre-emptive changes. Look for other plan providers to open up and disclose revenue sharing arrangements in order to avoid potential liability.

The case is also instructive in continuing the trend toward broader application of the term fiduciary with regard to retirement plans, especially small business 401(k) plans with typically higher and often hidden fees. 

With federal regulators evaluating fiduciary standards, look for more and more providers to fall under the functional fiduciary standard. The tougher and more expansive the standard, the more robust will be fee disclosures in everyday practice.

With all apologies to the great architect Louis Sullivan, "Frugal ever follows function."

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2025 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

By Lynn Cavanaugh | April 23, 2025

Since the Court took a worker-friendly approach on behalf of the University’s 28,000 employees in this excessive fees suit, the final ruling could burden plan fiduciaries and open the floodgates of meritless litigation, say retirement industry groups ERIC and the Spark Institute.

Supreme Court’s ruling in Cornell’s 403(b) 'high fees' case could bring a ‘tsunami’ of lawsuits

By Lynn Cavanaugh | April 23, 2025

Former employees had sued the grocery chain for failing to rein in recordkeeping costs from Fidelity, even though services were “routine” and did not justify the excessive costs, according to the class action lawsuit.

Whole Foods settles its 401(k) excessive fee lawsuit that cost workers millions

By Lynn Cavanaugh | April 22, 2025

The justices are now seeking input from the Department of Labor in this Home Depot case, after unanimously agreeing that the burden of proof lay with plan fiduciaries in the Cornell University excessive fee case last week.

Supreme Court wants DOL to weigh in on Home Depot’s 401(k) ‘excessive fee’ lawsuit
The Insider's Guide to Reliable Provider Directories for Brokerages and FMOs link

Guide

Sponsored by Zelis

The accuracy of your provider directories is vital to shaping your success. The guide provides actionable insights and best practices for ensuring the data you rely on is precise and trustworthy.

How One Employer Helped 1 in 3 Employees Improve Blood Pressure link

Case Study

Sponsored by Labcorp

High blood pressure affects nearly half of U.S. adults, increasing the risk of heart disease and stroke. This case study explores how an employer-sponsored wellness program helped approximately 1 in 3 employees improve their blood pressure risk level.

Reducing Employee Onboarding Time and Solving Staffing Challenges link

Case Study

Sponsored by Labcorp

Long onboarding times and staffing shortages create costly delays. Discover how one large healthcare system streamlined its hiring process, reducing onboarding time from weeks to days while improving the candidate experience and freeing up internal staff.