Hospitals sue to stop Trump on price transparency

Hospital groups are arguing the CMS's price transparency rule violates the First Amendment by provoking compelled speech.

By Marlene Satter | December 05, 2019 at 11:23 AM

The estimated costs to prepare the required data in compliance with the rule total between $38.7 to $39.4 million. (Photo: Shutterstock)

In their quest to preserve the rates they negotiate with insurance companies, hospitals have banded together to stop the Trump administration's price transparency rule.

According to The Hill, the American Hospital Association and other hospital groups have filed a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court in Washington that claims the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services rule violates the First Amendment by provoking compelled speech and goes beyond the intended meaning of "standard charges" transparency in the Affordable Care Act.

Related: CMS may lack authority to compel hospitals to tell negotiated prices

The suit also asks for an expedited decision, to spare hospitals the burden of having to sift through their complex mess of data should the rule end up being found unconstitutional.

It will be pricey for hospitals to comply, since the estimated costs to prepare the required data in compliance with the rule total between $38.7 to $39.4 million. According to the suit, "[t]he burden of compliance with the rule is enormous, and way out of line with any projected benefits associated with the rule."

In addition to decrying the onerousness of compliance, hospitals say that the end effect of the rule would mean that competitors would jack up their own prices to the point that consumers wouldn't seek care at all.

The suit also challenges the Department of Health and Human Services' authority for enforcement. "Instead of giving patients relevant information about costs, this rule will lead to widespread confusion and even more consolidation in the commercial health insurance industry," Rick Pollack, president and CEO of AHA, said in an AHA release. "We stand ready to work with CMS and other stakeholders to advance real solutions for patients."

HHS, naturally, has a different take on the matter. Says HHS spokeswoman Caitlin Oakley, "Hospitals should be ashamed that they aren't willing to provide American patients the cost of a service before they purchase it. President Trump and Secretary Azar are committed to providing patients the information they need to make their own informed health care decisions and will continue to fight for transparency in America's health care system."

Other groups that have signed on to the lawsuit include the Association of American Medical Colleges, the Children's Hospital Association and the Federation of American Hospitals.

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2025 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Marlene Satter

Marlene Y. Satter has worked in and written about the financial industry for decades.

By Alan Goforth | May 05, 2025

“Across a range of questions, large majorities of Democrats and independents oppose the Trump administration’s major cuts to federal health agencies and programs, while Republicans are more supportive,” the survey report said.

ACA subsidies, agency staffing cuts draw strong opposition, study finds

By Allison Bell | May 05, 2025

The early results for stop-loss claims, or claims for catastrophic losses, are in line with the insurer's expectations, company executives told analysts.

Cigna sees high level of employer health plan claims in 2025

By Allison Bell | May 05, 2025

The bill highlights the mixed messages about the issue coming out of the Trump administration.

House bill would let patients buy drugs from non-U.S. pharmacies
Benefit Strategy Savers: A Broker's Guide to Solving 2025 Benefit Challenges link

Guide

Sponsored by ArmadaCare

Discover how employer-paid supplemental health benefits can help close coverage gaps, reduce out-of-pocket costs, and boost retention!

Trends 2025: What to Watch in the Retirement Industry link

White Paper

Sponsored by TIAA

2025 is expected to bring increased market volatility, policy shifts, and new cybersecurity threats that could impact employee retirement savings. This white paper provides HR professionals with the insights they need to strengthen retirement benefits, support employee financial wellness, and navigate the evolving landscape with confidence.

Trends 2025: What to Watch in the Retirement Industry link

White Paper

Sponsored by TIAA

Following a year of relative market stability, 2025 is expected to bring increased market volatility, potential policy disruptions, and new cybersecurity threats that can put retirement savings at risk. This white paper equips advisory practices with crucial insights to navigate these challenges, implement effective lifetime income strategies, and guide clients toward a more secure retirement.