Democrats wrestle with competing ideas about how and where to cut health care proposals

Leaders are trending toward prioritizing extending the increase of the Obamacare subsidy and closing the Medicaid coverage gap.

By Alan Goforth | October 18, 2021 at 09:39 AM

Post-it notes with health reform cycle Senior aides say several unknowns will shape the decisions on health care, including where the overall spending level ends up. (Photo: Shutterstock)

Democrats continue to haggle over health care as they seek to trim more than $1 trillion from President Biden's proposed infrastructure spending plan, according to NBC News.

House leaders are trending toward prioritizing extending the increase of the Obamacare subsidy in the American Rescue Plan and closing the Medicaid coverage gap in states that didn't expand the program.

Recommended For You

"I feel very proprietary about the Affordable Care Act," said Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., who shepherded the bill into law in 2010 and embraces it as part of her legacy.

For House Majority Whip Jim Clyburn, D-S.C., a key figure who helped propel Biden into the White House, Medicaid is paramount. About 100,000 residents of his conservative state fall in the gap. "My priority is Medicaid and the coverage gap," he said.

Driving the push is Rep. Suzan DelBene, D-Wash., the leader of the 95-member New Democrat Coalition, who has urged party leaders to limit the health care provisions to ACA and Medicaid changes while leaving the expanded Medicare benefits for another day.

That isn't sitting well with Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., who has made the Medicare benefits a red line and — like every other senator in the 50-member Democratic caucus — holds a decisive vote.

"There really is something fundamentally wrong when, in the richest country in the history of the world, there are millions of seniors who have rotting teeth in their mouth, who are unable to hear what their grandchildren are saying, and study after study suggests that dementia is accelerated because people are isolated from their community because they can't hear," he told reporters. "So this to me is not negotiable. This is what the American people want."

Pelosi has said that programs will be scrapped in some cases and that expiration dates will be moved up to fit within the price range in others. Progressives see that as an invitation to fit some version of their policies in the final bill.

Senior aides say several unknowns will shape the decisions on health care. The first is where the overall spending level ends up. The second is how much the party can find in savings, which depends in large part on whether the bill allows Medicare to negotiate drug prices. Committees and policy writers are still waiting on guidance from leadership about those questions.

The ACA and Medicaid policies would cost $200 billion each, estimated Marc Goldwein, a policy expert with the nonpartisan Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget. The extra Medicare benefits would cost about $300 billion, with dental the costliest, he said, while cautioning that the numbers could change based on how they're structured. A policy for Medicare to negotiate drug prices could raise as much as $450 billion. The big question mark is centrist Sen. Kyrsten Sinema, D-Ariz., whose office has declined to confirm or deny reports that she opposes the proposal.

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2025 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

Alan Goforth

Alan Goforth is a freelance writer in suburban Kansas City. In addition to freelancing for several publications, he has written a dozen books about sports and other topics.

By Emily Payne | May 08, 2025

Our Advisor of the Year finalists shared the industry developments they're most excited about.

5 exciting things happening in the benefits industry

By Allison Bell | May 08, 2025

Some patients who face access restrictions may end up not using any medication, the analysts at GoodRx warn.

Commercial health plans cover more drugs without restrictions than Medicare, Medicaid: GoodRx

By Emily Payne | May 08, 2025

At this year’s Broker Expo, Lester Morales demonstrated how to connect data and health care spending -- without your audience’s eyes glazing over.

How to use data to tell a story about health care costs
Identifying Benefits Blind Spots: 3 Steps to Building a Well-Rounded Benefits Playbook link

Guide

Sponsored by New Benefits

Clients expect strategic advice, not just sales. This guide reveals 3 steps to audit benefits, fill gaps, and present holistic strategies that meet client goals and employee needs--positioning employee benefits brokers as trusted advisors.

Benefit Strategy Savers: A Broker's Guide to Solving 2025 Benefit Challenges link

Guide

Sponsored by ArmadaCare

Discover how employer-paid supplemental health benefits can help close coverage gaps, reduce out-of-pocket costs, and boost retention!

Trends 2025: What to Watch in the Retirement Industry link

White Paper

Sponsored by TIAA

2025 is expected to bring increased market volatility, policy shifts, and new cybersecurity threats that could impact employee retirement savings. This white paper provides HR professionals with the insights they need to strengthen retirement benefits, support employee financial wellness, and navigate the evolving landscape with confidence.